How a Bishop
is Chosen
Our Bishop: Diocese of La Crosse
As the people of the Diocese of
La Crosse learned that their bishop had been appointed
Archbishop of Saint Louis, many wondered how a new bishop would
be chosen. Who chooses a new bishop? This page was
prepared to answer that question for people of many Dioceses who
face the same situation.
The answer to the question "Who
chooses a new bishop?" is "The Holy Spirit." Christ has
not abandoned his church, and continues to guide and govern her
through the Holy Spirit. However, the Holy Spirit uses human
beings to accomplish this. Another correct answer is, "the
Pope." While it is true that the Pope can appoint any Catholic
priest to be a bishop, the actual process usually involves many
people.
The process consists of two
parts: identifying priests with the necessary qualities, and
selecting the one who best fills a specific vacancy. "We try to
find the saint who fits the niche," explained Archbishop Pio
Laghi, who served as apostolic delegate to the United States
from 1980 to 1990.
Identifying the right priests
The process of identifying
priests with the qualities desired in a bishop is an ongoing
process, even if there are no vacancies. The bishops of a
province (the Catholic Church in the United States is divided
into 33 provinces) give their archbishop the names of priests
they think would make good bishops. The Catholic Church in the
United States is divided into 33 provinces. The Diocese of La
Crosse belongs to the Milwaukee Province. Our archbishop is
Timothy Dolan, Archbishop of Milwaukee. The candidates passed
on by a bishop are usually from his current diocese or from one
where he has served, since these are the priests he knows best.
The qualities of a bishop
The church is very explicit
about the qualities that must be present in a candidate to the
episcopacy. He must be "a good pastor of souls and teacher of
the Faith." The church examines whether the candidates "enjoy a
good reputation; whether they are of irreproachable morality;
whether they are endowed with right judgment and prudence;
whether they are even-tempered and of stable character; whether
they firmly hold the orthodox Faith; whether they are devoted to
the Apostolic See and faithful to the magisterium of the church;
whether they have a thorough knowledge of dogmatic and moral
theology and canon law; whether they are outstanding for their
piety, their spirit of sacrifice and their pastoral zeal;
whether they have an aptitude for governing."
Consideration is also be given
to "intellectual qualities, studies completed, social sense,
spirit of dialogue and cooperation, openness to the signs of the
times, praise-worthy impartiality, family background, health,
age and inherited characteristics."
The provincial list
Periodically, the bishops of a
province meet under the chairmanship of their archbishop to
consider the names of priests who are possible candidates for
the episcopacy. At the provincial meeting, a list of candidates
for the episcopacy is assembled, voted on and forwarded to the
apostolic nuncio.
While the nuncio could nominate
for bishop someone not from this pool of candidates, and the
pope could appoint any priest he wanted, most appointments come
from these lists.
When a diocese becomes vacant,
the second part of the process gets underway – the search for
the specific person who will fill a specific vacancy.
The apostolic nuncio
A nuncio represents the Holy
Father to both a nation's civil government (as ambassador) and
the Catholic Church in that nation. The Most Rev. Gabriel
Montalvo, originally from Colombia and formerly rector of the
Vatican's diplomatic school has been the apostolic nuncio to the
United States since 1998.
When vacancies occur in U.S.
dioceses and a diocesan ordinary is being chosen (as opposed to
an auxiliary bishop), the nuncio chooses several candidates to
suggest to Rome from among the names which have been submitted.
The nuncio's recommendations to Rome are based on his own
extensive investigation of the needs of the diocese and each
candidate's suitability for that particular diocese. For
example, the Diocese of La Crosse has much rural territory. Our
Bishops have championed the needs of family farmers and have
demonstrated strong support of Catholic Schools..
During his investigation the
nuncio sends a confidential questionnaire on the candidate to
people who know him. The questions address the physical,
intellectual, moral, spiritual, social, and priestly
characteristics that one would hope for in a bishop.
Those questioned include
priests, religious and laity. Some are suggested by the priest's
diocesan bishop, others are diocesan officials or people the
nuncio has gotten to know personally. The laity consulted tend
to be officers in diocesan lay organizations or on diocesan
advisory committees. Each is told to answer the questions
without consulting others. They cannot tell anyone, especially
the candidate, that they have received the questionnaire.
Nuncio's Report
After the nuncio has examined
the responses to the questionnaires, he prepares the "terna," a
list of three candidates, and writes a report extracting and
synthesizing the content of the consultation and giving his own
judgment. The terna and the report are sent to the Congregation
for Bishops in Rome, and no bishop sees them unless he is a
member of that congregation. The report gives a description of
the diocese, describes the process the nuncio went through in
selecting the candidates, describes the candidates and gives the
nuncio's recommendations.
Congregation for Bishops
When the nuncio's report
arrives at the Congregation for Bishops, the members discuss the
appointment under the chairmanship of the prefect. The
congregation then votes on the candidates and attaches its own
recommendations to the report.
The Pope
The final step in the
appointment process occurs when the prefect of the Congregation
for Bishops presents the nuncio's, the congregation's, and his
own recommendations to the pope in a private audience. The
prefect summarizes the discussions of the congregation and
reports any dissenting opinions. The pope may ask for more
information about the candidates, or may even ask for other
candidates to be proposed. In the end however, the pope, led by
the Holy Spirit, makes the appointment.
Notification and consent
After the pope makes his
decision, the nuncio is notified, who then approaches the
nominee and asks if he will accept the appointment. When the
candidate accepts, Rome is notified and a date is set for the
announcement.
Although the process normally
takes four to eight months, it can be much shorter or much
longer. And so the Diocese of La Crosse waited patiently for
more than a year while the Holy Spirit leads the church to the
best bishop possible – the "saint who fits the niche."
May the Holy Spirit be active
in the process of selecting new bishops. May they be men of
deep faith, integrity, fidelity and compassion. Let's pray
daily!
In the mean time.
When a Bishop is transferred he
continues to function as Diocesan Administrator. He will
continue to fulfill the responsibilities of Diocesan Bishop but
with care not to introduce any innovation or to prejudice any
aspect of the governance of the Diocese for his successor, in
accord with Canons 427 and 428. With the announcement those
appointed by the Bishop cease to be Vicar General and Episcopal
Vicar. They will however, continue to assist the Bishop in the
governance of the Diocese and especially in his care for the
presbyterate of the Diocese.
It is no longer possible for
the Bishop to make any major new decisions for the Diocese, for
example, regarding the status of parishes or buildings and
remodeling projects. Decisions already made and directives
already given, of course, remain in force.
After the Bishop has moved and
has been installed in his new Diocese or Archdiocese, the
College of Consultors will assume the administration of the
Diocese until it is able to elect a diocesan administrator
(Canons 419 and 421). Upon election, the diocesan administrator
will assume the administration of the Diocese until a new bishop
is installed or takes possession of the Diocese (Canon 430).
The Presbyteral Council will lapse until the Ninth Bishop of La
Crosse reconvenes it (Canon 501).
Until his installation in his
new Diocese the Bishop is mentioned in the usual way during the
Eucharistic Prayer of Mass. After his installation on though,
the prayer for the Diocesan Bishop will be suppressed in the
Eucharistic Prayer, until the new Bishop is appointed.